Russia Is Our Friend
By David
Swanson | Aug 6, 2018
The Kremlin
in Moscow, Russia (Pavel Kazachkov)
Russia must
be a true friend indeed to have put up with the US government’s international
aggression for all these years.
Last May I
was in Russia when fascists held a rally in my hometown of Charlottesville, not
to be confused with their larger rally which followed in August. At the May
rally, people shouted “Russia is our friend.” I was on a Russian TV show called
Crosstalk the next day and discussed this. I also discussed
it with other Russians, actual friends in the human sense. Some of them were
completely bewildered, arguing that Russia never
had slavery and couldn’t be the friend of Confederate-flag-waving people whom
they saw as advocates for slavery. (Anti-Russian Ukrainians have also waved
Confederate flags.)
I don’t
think slavery or serfdom were on the minds of the people shouting “Russia is
our friend.” Rather they believed the Democratic/Liberal accusation that the
Russian government had tried to help make Donald Trump President, and they
approved. They may also have thought of Russia as a “white” ally in their cause of white supremacy.
I think
there is a case to made that, in fact, in a very different sense, “Russia is
our friend.” It’s a case that could fill volumes. I don’t make this case
suffering under some delusion of the perfect saintliness of the Russian
government, neither now nor at any time in history. In 2015, the Russian
military approached me and asked if I would publish their propaganda under my
own name. I told them to go to hell publicly. I’ve had Russian media
censor my criticisms of Russia and highlight my criticisms of the United States
(yet allow more criticism of Russia than big U.S. media allows criticism of
U.S. foreign policy).
I make the
following case because I think it is overwhelming yet fervently ignored. I’ll
just note a few highlights.
While the
United States and Russia were war allies during World War I, the United States,
in 1917, sent funding to one side, the anti-revolutionary side of a Russian
civil war, worked to blockade the Soviet Union, and, in 1918, sent U.S. troops
to Murmansk, Archangel, and Vladivostok in an attempt to overthrow the new
Russian government. They abandoned the effort and withdrew in April, 1920. Most
people in the United States do not know this, but many more
Russians do.
The threat
of the communists, as an example, albeit a deeply flawed one, of taking wealth
away from oligarchs was a driving force in U.S. foreign affairs from 1920 up
to, all during, and long after World War II. Senator and future president Harry
Truman was far from alone in wishing to help the Russians
if the Germans were winning, but the Germans if the Russians were winning, so
that more of both would die. Senator Robert Taft proclaimed an elite view, shared
by some West Point generals, that a victory for fascism would be better than a
victory for communism. Wall Street had helped to build up Nazi Germany.
Without the help of IBM, General
Motors, Ford, Standard Oil, and other U.S. businesses right through the war,
the Nazis could not have done what they did. The U.S. government was complicit
in these acts of treason, avoiding bombing U.S. factories in Germany, and even
compensating U.S. businesses for damage when hit.
The
Russians had turned the tide against the Nazis outside Moscow and begun pushing
the Germans back before the United States ever entered World War II. The
Soviets implored the United States to attack Germany from the west from that
moment until the summer of 1944 — that is to say, for two-and-a-half years.
Wanting the Russians to do most of the killing and dying — which they did — the U.S. and Britain
also did not want the Soviet Union making a new deal with or taking sole
control of Germany. The allies agreed that any defeated nation would have to
surrender to all of them and completely. The Russians went along with this.
Yet in
Italy, Greece, France, etc., the U.S. and Britain cut Russia out almost
completely, banned communists, shut out leftist resisters to the Nazis, and
re-imposed rightwing governments that the Italians called “fascism without
Mussolini.” The U.S. would “leave behind” spies and terrorists and
saboteurs in various European countries to fend off any communist influence.
Originally
scheduled for the first day of Roosevelt’s and Churchill’s meeting with Stalin
in Yalta, the U.S. and British bombed the city of Dresden flat, destroying its
buildings and its artwork and its civilian population, apparently as a means of
threatening Russia. The United States then developed and used on Japanese cities
nuclear bombs, a decision driven largely by the
desire to see Japan surrender to the United States alone, without the Soviet
Union, and by the desire to threaten the Soviet Union.
Immediately
upon German surrender, Winston Churchill proposed using Nazi troops
together with allied troops to attack the Soviet Union, the nation that had
just done the bulk of the work of defeating the Nazis. This was not an
off-the-cuff proposal. The U.S. and British had
sought and achieved partial German surrenders, had kept German troops armed and
ready, and had debriefed German commanders on lessons learned from their
failure against the Russians. Attacking the Russians sooner rather than later
was a view advocated by General George Patton, and by Hitler’s replacement
Admiral Karl Donitz, not to mention Allen Dulles and the OSS. Dulles made a separate
peace with Germany in Italy to cut out the Russians, and began sabotaging
democracy in Europe immediately and empowering former Nazis in Germany, as well
as importing them into the U.S.
military to focus on war against Russia.
The war
launched was a cold one. The U.S. worked to make sure that West German
companies would rebuild quickly but not pay war reparations owed to the Soviet
Union. While the Soviets were willing to withdraw from countries like Finland,
their demand for a buffer between Russia and Europe hardened as the U.S.-led
Cold War grew, in particular the oxymoronic “nuclear diplomacy.”
Lies about
Soviet threats and missile gaps and Russian tanks in Korea and global communist
conspiracies became the biggest profit makers for U.S. weapons companies, not
to mention Hollywood movie studios, in history, as well as the biggest threat
to peace in various corners of the globe. The United States drew Russia into a war in
Afghanistan and armed its opponents. Efforts at nuclear disarmament and
diplomacy, which more often than not came from the Soviet side, were routinely
thwarted by Americans. When Eisenhower and Khrushchev seemed likely to talk
peace, a U.S. spy plane was shot down, just after an American who’d been
involved with those planes defected to Russia. When
Kennedy seemed interested in peace, he was killed, purportedly by that very
same American.
When
Germany reunited, the United States and allies lied to the Russians that NATO
would not expand. Then NATO quickly began expanding eastward. Meanwhile the United
States openly bragged about imposing Boris
Yeltsin and corrupt crony capitalism on Russia by interfering in a Russian
election in collusion with Yeltsin. NATO developed into a aggressive global war
maker and expanded right up to Russia’s
borders, where the United States began installing missiles. Russian requests to
join NATO or Europe were dismissed out of hand. Russia was to remain a designated enemy, even without the
communism, and even without constituting any threat or engaging in any
hostility.
When Russia
gave the United States a memorial in sorrow for the victims of 9/11, the United
States practically hid it, and reported on it so little that most people don’t
know it exists or believe it’s a false story.
When Russia
has proposed to make treaties on weapons in space or cyber war or nuclear
missiles, the United States has regularly rejected such moves. Russia’s
advocacy for the Iran agreement meant nothing. Obama and Trump have expelled
Russian diplomats. Obama helped facilitate a coup in Ukraine. Trump has begun weapons
shipments to the coup government, which includes Nazis. Obama tried to
facilitate an overthrow in Syria. Trump escalated the bombings, even hitting
Russian troops. Trump accuses Russia — the one allied power not still
occupying Germany — of dominating Germany, while trying to prevent Russia from
selling its fossil fuels.
Russia is
accused, and found guilty prior to convincing evidence, of shooting down an
airplane, of “aggressively” flying near U.S. planes on Russia’s borders, of
“conquering” Crimea through a popular vote, of poisoning people in England, of
torturing and murdering a man in prison, and of
course of “hacking” an election — an
accusation which, if evidence is ever produced for it, will amount to far less
than Israel does in the United States or than the United States does in many
countries. Through all of these accusations it is not uncommon for the Russians
to be referred to as “the commies,” despite the demise of communism.
What, you
may ask, does any of this have to do with Russia being a friend? Simply this:
nobody other than a friend would put up with this shit.
This
article was originally published at DavidSwanson.org on August 5, 2018.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.